When we talk about football clubs with a rich history and legendary status, Ajax, the Dutch giants, always comes to mind. Named after a Greek mythological legend, Ajax’s lore is unique, cementing its status as a legendary name in the beautiful game.
A nightmarish campaign in season 2023/24
However, despite their status as the biggest club in the Netherlands, Ajax endured a woeful campaign in season 2023/24. The club from the Dutch capital finished in fifth place in the Eredivisie table, a massive 35 points adrift of eventual champions PSV Eindhoven.
It was quite simply a season to forget. Can we do better on FM24 in season 2023/24? Here is what happened as we attempted to improve upon Ajax’s woeful campaign.
We certainly experienced an improved campaign
How I approached this experiment was similar to how I do tactics testing. I simmed a whole season without any transfers or changes whatsoever.
This means that our save played out the season with the same players that were available to the club in real life. We used a 4-3-3 tactic, in this case, Samzoid’s Elite 2341, which has proven to be a popular formation at the club in the past.
Real-life finish vs our FM24 save Ajax
As we know, Ajax finished fifth place in the Eredivisie last season. During the campaign, the Amsterdammers picked up just 56 points, one of their lowest points tallies in decades.
Ajax scored 74 goals and conceded 61 at the other end of the pitch, which, in reality, would not be bad for a midtable team. However, for a team like Ajax, it was poor.
It was easy to top those tallies on FM24, as our team scored 82 goals but crucially conceded just 32 and was crowned as Dutch champions.
Only second-place reigning champions Feyenoord enjoyed a better defensive record. The latter played a key role in the title-winning campaign, as the team kept 15 clean sheets.
We had a situation that I have very rarely seen in FM, as two goalkeepers played close to half the games each over the campaign. Argentinian stopper Geronimo Rulli made 16 Eredivisie appearances, while youngster Diant Ramaj played 18 times.
In real life, Ramaj was the first choice in the Dutch top flight, starting 20 times, while Rulli and Jay Gorter also made seven starts each. It is fair to say the Ajax keepers performed better on FM24 than in real life.
Top performers in real life vs our FM24 save
Strangely, the top two top goalscorers on FM24 and in real life were the same two players. In both, highly-rated young striker Brian Brobbey topped the goalscoring charts. He performed better in real life, scoring 18 goals and producing eight assists.
On our save, winger Steven Bergwijn was the joint top goalscorer with 15 goals, but he also produced seven assists. In season 2023/24, he scored 12 goals and produced four assists. That shows he slightly underachieved in real life last season.
Central midfielder Kenneth Taylor was another player who flourished in our save. The Netherlands international scored an impressive 11 goals and also produced 11 assists on our save. His performances, in reality, were slightly less impressive for Taylor, who scored a respectable five goals and produced five assists.
Young winger Carlos Borges/Forbs (His name seems to be different depending on where you read it) was relatively prolific in FM24, scoring nine times and producing five assists.
His numbers for Ajax in season 2023/24 were not great. However, that was probably because just eight of his 21 appearances during the campaign came from the start. He scored just two goals and produced three assists.
One of my favourite FM players, Borna Sosa, enjoyed a frustrating debut campaign in Amsterdam. He made just 16 appearances for the club from the Dutch capital, only 10 of which came from the start. He produced four assists in those appearances.
He produced far better results on FM24, scoring three goals and picking up a team-high 14 assists.
Veteran winger Steven Berghuis also produced respectable assist figures. He had ten assists and six goals in just 22 appearances. In reality, he scored five goals and made eight assists.
Midfielder Branco van den Boomen impressed on our save, scoring seven goals and producing five assists in 36 appearances, 18 of which came from the start and 18 from the substitute bench.
The midfielder played a bit-part role in real life, scoring two goals in 11 starts and ten substitute appearances.
Young defender Devyne Rensch was also another player who performed far better in our save than in real life, well, going forward, anyway. He scored five goals and picked up seven assists, compared to his real-life tally of two goals and four assists.
Former Liverpool and England midfield star Jordan Henderson enjoyed a decent campaign on our save, scoring eight and assisting eight goals.
Judging him on his real-life efforts would be harsh, as he only joined the Amsterdammers from Saudi Pro League Al-Ettifaq in the January transfer window.
The former England international produced three assists from just nine appearances, which is not a terrible return from the centre of the park. The team may have performed better if he had been at Ajax from the start of the campaign.
A player who performed better in real life than on our save was promising young midfielder Kristian Hlynsson, who scored seven goals and produced one assist.
In our save, Hlynsson made just five starts while making 17 substitute appearances, scoring two goals and producing four assists.
What is our conclusion?
I am not sure how Ajax made winning the Eredivisie such hard work in season 2023/24. It was easy!
Joking aside, the problems at Ajax were a perfect storm. The squad has been getting weaker and weaker in recent transfer windows.
Meanwhile, there has been no continuity in the coaching staff, as the team has struggled for form since Erik ten Hag’s exit to Manchester United in 2022.
The 2024/25 season will likely be much improved, as the team obviously underperformed. It’s hard to see another repeat of the woeful 2023/24 campaign.
Have you ever managed Ajax in FM24, and how did you do?